XII.

[alt_lana]

The new term is off to a brisk start, and I'm pleased to see that everyone seems to have settled back into their daily routines with a minimum of fuss. Of course, it would be well if some of our number could stiffen their spines and rely a bit less on Madam Pomfrey to console them for every chill or nightmare or pinched finger. I mentioned to the Headmistress yesterday that it would be perfectly fair to charge a small fee to those who use so much more than their share of the Matron's resources.

It's difficult to believe that this first month of the new year is nearly halfway through--and there is so much on the schedule for its second half! This Thursday is the next meeting of the Duelling Club (and again on the 28th and alternate Thursdays for the remainder of the year). On Saturday, as everyone must surely be aware, Ravenclaw and Slytherin meet on the pitch for a game that may well determine this year's House Cup, but which will, in any case, be a stoutly fought battle of wills between two fine teams. May the best side win!

The following Saturday will see the first Young Protector's League meeting of the new term. I believe that Professor Sinistra means to announce her plans for that gathering very soon, so I will say no more here. Do keep an eye out for the sign-up list on her office door.


LAVERTY: Did you get the note I asked Perks to give you? I was expecting to see you after lunch today in the usual place, but you didn't show. There's something very important Johns and I need to discuss with you before tomorrow evening. We'll look for you after breakfast, but it's imperative we connect by lunch at the latest. (You've seen the list, of course, so you may have an idea what we'd like to propose. I promise you'll be well-served by it.)

Comments

[alt_lucius]

I could not agree more that children need to learn consequences to their actions.

Perhaps you would care to Cruciate each of them, seeing as how the effects of that spell on reinforcing bladder control are well-known. As well as hypochondria.

[alt_lana]

I beg your pardon?

[alt_lucius]

You may, though I am more interested to know your justification for the use of the curse in last night's excitement.

You propose to disincentivise children from indulging in night fears or other irrational behaviour. My point, young lady, is that behaviour which is inherently irrational cannot necessarily be deterred by rational appeal. Even an extreme measure such as the threat of the Cruciatus may not be a guarantee of self-control in the face of an unchecked compulsion. (Indeed, I see that Bellatrix has noted the lengths to which people will go to avoid the ordeal. Hence you will agree that the threat of the curse is a tool to be used carefully and not capriciously.)

On the other hand, the pattern established by a child who persists in difficulty, even after the introduction of consequences, may well be concealing a deeper worriment, of which their conduct is merely an outward sign.

I assure you, you are not the first to express annoyance at the foolishness of your younger charges, nor shall you be the last. I can certainly sympathise, for the shepherding of the inane is one of the less desirable responsibilities falling to the Head Boy and Girl.

What I wonder, however, is whether these incidents betray a more fundamental source for anxiety. Look beyond the surface action to determine whether their repeated trouble is simply a case of having been coddled, or whether it bears further investigation.

[alt_lana]

I'm sure you are right when you suggest that if imposing reasonable consequences fails to correct the behaviour of a child it suggests a deeper issue, but surely that is a reason to establish deterrents appropriate to the troublesome behaviour. Currently there are none with respect to the Matron's services, and my suggestion to the Headmistress was that it might be time to implement some measures to prevent abuse of Madam Pomfrey's time and resources.

I confess that I'm not certain whether we are in agreement or disagreement on that point.

My proposal of a small fine as the disincentive measure was presented as a suggestion, and there may well be a deterrent better suited to this particular problem. It is now in the Headmistress's hands whether she feels the suggestion worthy of further consideration.

As for my use of the Cruciatus curse last night, I acted there in my role as a head student in the presence of witnesses and under the supervision of a teacher. I stand by my use of the curse in the circumstances. I can certainly not be accused of overusing that method for responding to disruptive students, as this was the first time I have attempted the curse. I see that Professor Carrow has already informed you that he found my first effort unsatisfactory and instructed me in its better application on a second attempt.

Certainly Cruciatus is not a disincentive to be used in all situations or to be abused, but it does appear to have a pronounced effect not only on the student who was subject to its disciplinary effects but also on her peers.

[alt_lucius]

I believe it is for the Matron to decide and track, given her extensive experience, whether the demand for her resources has exceeded years past. I remain dubious, though I could be convinced, that a fine of any kind will be any more efficacious than any other deterrent, regardless of how reasonable or not. A child who is afraid in the night, whether due to a real or an imagined threat, is unlikely to be assuaged by the thought of incurring a debt, any more than that child is apt to become less frightened by more extreme penalties, such as the idea that if she seeks assistance, she is likely to fall under Cruciation for her trouble.

Regarding your use of that valuable weapon, I was not questioning your authority, but the circumstances which you defend so readily. Presumably there was some provocation to the incident that has not yet been disclosed; Professor Carrow's presence and his subsequent use of the incident as a teaching tool are, sadly, not necessarily the most ringing endorsement, though I do not for a moment doubt that he encouraged its further application. As your mentor pointed out, the use of the curse is something that takes a considerable amount of commitment. Whether or not you believe you possess the qualifications necessary to determine that the situation warrants the Cruciatus, applying the curse on a fellow student for any reason less than absolute need may secure you a reputation as a fearsome opponent, but not necessarily as a confidante, to whom one can apply for succor when needed (and in whom one may entrust one's secrets).

Bella counsels you to harden yourself and there is much to be said for that advice, particularly if that is the direction in which your personality leads you. Too many of the demands on an Auror require resolute stoicism in the face of our enemies' rancor. There is also a great deal of merit to remaining approachable, so that you may also draw in those who would otherwise have reason to hide their anxieties. Perhaps you are familiar with the phrase 'Good Auror / Bad Auror'?

[alt_lana]

Thank you for your counsel, Mr Malfoy. I will give it due consideration along with Mrs Lestrange's words.

[alt_amycus]

She needs to refine her technique a bit, for that to be useful, though.

She'll get better with practise, I daresay.

[alt_lucius]

As will her judgement of when it is warranted, one presumes.

Not that I object to her proving to her charges that she is capable - but one must take care that the example set sends the right message, as well.